Dental Payroll Question

I’ve got a small practice with 5 employees, and I’ve been doing the payroll and taxes myself with Quickbooks. I’m tired of doing it and thinking of having a service do it for me. I’ve talked with Paychex and they sound good for about 100 bucks a month I get full service tax and payroll. Anyone have any other recommendations? Anyone have any experience using Paychex?

As a dental CPA in a dental CPA firm I have a lot of experience comparing Paychex & ADP.

Back in the late 80’s when we decided as a firm that handling payroll processing was NOT in our best interest as a service we started researching which payroll firms we would want to refer our clients to.

Paychex was our choice & they received nearly all of our referrals for many years.

Occasionally clients have issues with them & sometimes it’s the clients fault, sometimes it’s the dedicated payroll specialists fault.

We’d then refer to ADP or some of the other local services, like Primepay.

Most can do a decent job, however, it does seem to me that we get more client complaints about ADP when compared to Paychex & MORE of our clients use Paychex.

We also found that ADP’s reporting after each payroll was too cumbersome for our clients, simply too much paper work which 75% wasn’t even usedlooked at.

Paychex reporting was much more streamlined & easier to read for most clients.

As a firm we used Paychex, switched to another local service, ADP bought them out so we wound up with ADP.

I wasn’t involved in the selection process, however, I do understand that the reasons why our firm initially changed was cost & issues with our payroll specialist.

This post first appeared on DentalTown.

Send your questions to Tim Lott, CPA, CVA at

For more information or to sign up for our newsletter, please contact
Follow us on TwitterFacebook and Pinterest